Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 25

Thread: Geoff Dyer: Zona

  1. #1

    United Kingdom Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Zona – Geoff Dyer
    Canongate £16.99
    Reviewed by Leyla Sanai

    A gambler trying to guess the topic of a future Geoff Dyer book would always be destined to lose. Not only is Dyer versatile in form (novels, novellas, essays, non-fiction books), but his range of chosen topics has been so eclectic to date that predicting the next would be impossible.


    As far as non-fiction is concerned, Dyer’s panoramic sweep has included the sacred – *history, literature, photography, jazz – as well as the profane – sex, drugs, Burning Man. Speaking at the Edinburgh Book Festival he said in 2010 that the conventional notion that one had to be an expert in a subject before writing about it was one he rebelled against, and that with some of his chosen subjects, he embarked on writing the book with an interest in his topic but limited detailed knowledge, allowing the research process to educate him while he wrote the book.


    Dyer was certainly very knowledgeable about the iconic Russian filmmaker Andrei Tarkovsky’s 1979 art-house movie Stalker before he started writing this book, having seen it repeatedly over the more than thirty years since its release. The first time he saw it he didn’t enjoy it that much, but its slow, haunting scenes lodged in his mind, and he was compelled to see it again and again.


    Stalker is a typical Tarkovsky film, slow, mysterious, allegorical. The central story involves a guide, the Stalker, taking a Writer and a Professor to a forbidden zone where, it is rumoured, one’s deepest desires come true. There is a constant drizzle during filming, and the industrial wasteland the three travel through to reach the zone is scattered with the deserted warehouses, disused railway stations and debris of urban life – abandoned cars, telegraph poles – *that was characteristic of parts of north London, where I lived when I saw the movie. Tarkovsky was Russian Orthodox by religion, and his rendering of an inaccessible place where dreams come true had spiritual undertones.


    Dyer is eloquent on how the mindless immediacy of modern living taints our appreciation of a film like Stalker. We are conditioned to not wait longer than a few seconds for anything, we become impatient quickly, and western films are quick-fire productions where action and dialogue fill the space around us constantly. This engenders impatience when we are asked by a director to sit and watch scenes where nothing much happens for what seems like long periods of time. But once we give ourselves over to the dreamy, unhurried pace, we can sink into the film and become mesmerised.

    *
    Dyer’s writing is as precise and crisp as ever. His insights are perceptive and intelligent, his mind quick, sharp and witty. On almost every page his discursive style probes into related topics. There is a lot of fascinating information about filming, such as how Tarkovsky’s first choice of site was unavailable. Since the damp, drizzly urban wasteland seems so well suited to the film, it seems fortuitous that this was the case. But the river that flowed near the site of filming was a dumping site for industrial waste, and Tarkovsky’s wife among others, died of cancer. The film also suffered many set-backs, including damage to the reels of film that meant that months of work had to be re-shot.

    *
    Because this is Dyer, the book is laugh out loud funny. Some of the anecdotes are about Tarkovsky, who colourfully described various crew members as ‘childish degenerates’, ‘cretins’, ‘lightweight shallow people with no self respect’, and ‘behaving like bastards’. Others are about other films. For example, the Turkish director Nuri Ceylan referenced Stalker in his 2002 film Distant by having the protagonist transfixed to a videotape of Stalker playing on his living room TV, while his uncouth cousin, an uninvited guest is visibly bored. *His cousin, unimpressed by the art house movie, *leaves the room, whereupon the protagonist switches to watching pornography. But the cousin returns to the room, causing the main character to switch hastily over to some brainless programme which the guest enjoys. The host grumpily announces that the TV is being switched off for the night.


    Just as delightful are the snippets of autobiographical detail. We hear about Dyer’s parents’ frugality, in particular his mother’s illogical refusal to spend a little more on buying the kind of steak she actually enjoyed eating. We find out about Dyer’s *friendlessness in sixth form, and his mother pressurising his father to go out to the pub with Geoff, and his knowledge that his father would far rather stay at home and save the money. There is an interesting anecdote about Dyer’s wife’s one time resemblance to Natascha McElhone, the actress. It is fabulous learning more about Dyer, such as his desire not simply for a dog but for the very dog that belongs to close friends, and no other. Dyer is such a charming raconteur, so effortlessly hilarious, that it would be impossible to become bored by his side-tracks. Like David Foster Wallace, his footnotes and side-tracks are often greater gems than the main subject he is exploring.


    Dyer is, as Zadie Smith said, a national treasure. Zona is another example of the way his brilliant mind takes high culture and makes it not only understandable, but creates a fabulously entertaining journey along the way.
    Last edited by leyla; 11-Feb-2012 at 15:47.

  2. #2

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer - Zona

    I couldn't decide whether or not to keep in a few paragraphs from the middle about wanting to see more of Dyer's emotional depth. My partner said it was intrusive, so I cut it out. Then other people said they didn't, so I put those paragraphs back into the version on my blog. But since every time I copy and paste from my blog or from my ipad word processing app, Pages, the text comes out in one solid chunk without paragraph spacings, I really feel it is beyond me to put those extra paragraphs back here. (Removing them and reformatting took me an hour. I know, I know, I'm a technical idiot.) Anyone who wants to read the version with those paragraphs in can look on my blog here:

    http://www.rocksbackpagesblogs.com/2012/02/48375/

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Boston, USA
    Posts
    3,617

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer - Zona

    Thank you, Leyla, for a lovely review. I ordered the book yesterday and will read it in the next few days (after it arrives in the mail).

  4. #4

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Thank you, Liam. I hope you enjoy the book. Let us know what you think of it.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Location
    Boston
    Posts
    174

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Great review. I am looking forward to this book. I love both Dyer and Tarkovsky. I admire the former for his willingness to mix things up and experiment with his writing - not just sticking within the conventions of fiction.

  6. #6

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Thanks, miobrien. I too love Dyer's unconventionality and his segues into personal revelations, some of them shocking. From a writer lacking his brilliance, intellect and wit, they might not work, but he carries them off wonderfully.

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Sep 2009
    Location
    Buenos Aires, Argentina
    Posts
    1,158

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Very interesting review. Reminds me that I haven't yet watched Stalker. I need to do that ASAP and then read Dyer's book.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Posts
    753

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Put it on my wish-list together with Tarkovsky's Sculpting in Time, which I also still have not read yet even though being a huge admirer of his films (shame on me!).

  9. #9

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Yes, I really want to see Stalker again, and some of Tarkovsky's other films.I think in this era of short attention spans and hundreds of stimuli all vying for one's attention at the same time, it's harder to find three hours of quiet time when one can watch a film uninterrupted. I really like the way Dyer describes that phenomenon at the beginning of the book; the fact that initially one resists the notion of sitting quietly for so long, but once one surrenders to the slow pace, one becomes engrossed.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Boston, USA
    Posts
    3,617

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    So I'm back from reading Dyer's Zona and my god, what a trainwreck.

    Leyla's review is excellent, as always; where I disagree with her strongly is in her assessment of this book as "brilliant."

    I thought it was shallow, lazy, vulgar and irrelevant.

    Dyer does not strike me as a great mind, on any level, which is why people like him should desist from writing about the great minds of others. His analysis of Tarkovsky's Stalker is superficial beyond belief, neither here nor there, interspersed with a bunch of boring personal anecdotes that bear no relevance to the topic at hand.

    The film is ultimately a meditation, but it is pristinely structured, shot by shot. Dyer's little book, on the other hand, is written as if the author got high on weed before sitting down to write it.

    The ultimate joke, of course, is that he complains, time and again, about how our culture leaves us no room for reflection, about how Hollywood shortens our attention spans, and then he goes on to produce a short, uncomplicated and very sparsely written book that is perfect reading for people with ADD.

    Throughout his ramblings, Dyer discusses (that is to say, dismisses) other great directors like Antonioni, Bergman, Bresson and the Coen Brothers as boring; meanwhile, Tarantino gets praised as innovative; how much you're going to trust his assessment of Tarkovsky after this, is up to you.

    One should never read two or more books at the same time, if one can help it, but before embarking on the failed voyage of reading Zona I was deeply engrossed in Tim Robinson's 1,000-pp. travelogue of the Aran Islands, published in two volumes (Pilgrimage & Labyrinth) and it struck me that Robinson's prolonged, cosmic, spiritual, emotional journey was everything that Dyer's wasn't.

    The first volume especially reads like an honest, humble, yet incredibly well-informed homage (read: pilgrimage) to the place and time that Robinson was in love with; meanwhile Dyer's musings come across, in comparison, as superficially flimsy and inconsequential.

    Perhaps I'm comparing apples and oranges. Perhaps.

    But there's nothing like reading a good book side-by-side with a bad one to bring home to you how truly awful some forms of "personal" writing are.

  11. #11
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Posts
    753

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Damn it, I already got rid of the Sight and Sound volume where the book is reviewed. As far as I remember the reviewer was quite enthusiastic about the Dyer book, but I cannot remember any specifics. But I also remember reading reviews that were not as enthusiastic.

    Liam have you finished the book already? Maybe it becomes better later?

  12. #12

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Liam, I guess that illustrates the total subjectivity of the reading experience. I like writers who stray off topic if they do it in a way that I find compelling, and their asides are as interesting as the topic from which they've swerved. It does drive me mad with frustration in writers whose digressions I don't find fascinating, though - I just want to scream 'get back to the point.'The one thing about which I do agree with you is the shallowness at a crucial point where I as a reader wanted more. Did you read the version of my review on my blog? In there I state that although I found it entertaining to hear about Dyer's sexual fantasies ( when he talks about his greatest wish in the world being - to have a threesome.) It would have been preferable to me if he'd shown a bit more of his soul. We can't all be George Clooney (someone with depth, talent, humour, personality * and* looks), but being flippant and witty the whole time means Dyer doesn't reveal much about his inner self.

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Boston, USA
    Posts
    3,617

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Quote Originally Posted by leyla View Post
    Did you read the version of my review on my blog?
    I did, dear, and it was an excellent piece of work (made me pick up the book in the first place, so it worked, didn't it? ).

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    France
    Posts
    437

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    I'm afraid I just wish the ubiquitous Geoff Dyer would go away--or at the very least publish only in the British Isles. Am I the only one?

  15. #15

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Thanks Liam!x

  16. #16
    Join Date
    Nov 2009
    Location
    France
    Posts
    437

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Okay, so it seems I'm the only one on WLF who wishes Dyer would just go away or at least be banished from the pages of American magazines and papers. As you can imagine, then, I was somewhat heartened--and very much amused--by the first comment (by most recommended) to this piece by Dyer, which, as with nearly all of Dyer's pieces, I couldn't bear to read more than three lines of.

  17. #17
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Boston, USA
    Posts
    3,617

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    ^^Well, you're hardly the only one. Zona was my first foray into Dyer, and I came away disgusted, so I doubt I'll be paying him much attention in the future. I think Leyla is being too indulgent toward his lazy brand of storytelling, .

  18. #18
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Posts
    753

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Scott Esposito writes about the book here:

    But with Zona Dyer has misfired. Too much of its prose is flabby, too many of its conclusions are easily won.
    http://bnreview.barnesandnoble.com/t5/Reviews-Essays/Zona-A-Book-about-a-Film-about-a-Journey-to-a-Room/ba-p/7317



    Last edited by Rumpelstilzchen; 26-Mar-2012 at 17:23.

  19. #19

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    I think with Zona it really helps to be very interested in Tarkovsky's film. So it's a very esoteric subject for a book. I enjoyed Dyer's musings more than the frame by frame analysis of the movie. I'd recommend Jeff in Paris/Death in Varanassi, which is a pair of linked novellas, as a good intro to Dyer, since the first novella is very funny. It also contains lots of explicit sex, so don't read if you find that off-putting. I also really enjoyed his Working the Room, which was a collection of essays on an eclectic range of topics. Not all the topics will appeal to everyone, but hopefully some will. I think he's an immensely talented writer.

  20. #20
    Join Date
    Oct 2008
    Location
    Boston, USA
    Posts
    3,617

    Default Re: Geoff Dyer: Zona

    Another review of the book.

Similar Threads

  1. Geoff Dyer: Working The Room
    By leyla in forum European Literature
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 14-Nov-2010, 12:36
  2. Geoff Dyer: The Missing of the Somme
    By BlogSpy in forum The Blogosphere
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 21-Nov-2008, 08:13

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •