waalkwriter
Reader
We all like to ridicule and bitch at the Nobels. I decided it'd be nice to have a specific place to lay out grievances and make ourselves feel better by criticizing a prominent literary awards winners and non-winners.
I was going to say other things, but then it struck me that wow, has no other country been quite as thoroughly screwed over by the award as England? Here are the Britishers that won the award:
John Galsworthy
Ruyard Kipling
Bertrand Russell
Winston Churchill
William Golding
Harold Pinter
Doris Lessing
However,
E.M. Forester
D.H. Lawrence
Virginia Woolf
Dylan Thomas
E.H. Auden
W.E. Housmann
J.R. Tolkien
Graham Greene and
Evelyn Waugh
did not win. I can't think of any country that has been more screwed. William Golding was a lightweight with one so-so work, and they passed up Graham Greene's lifetime of work simply because one of the Committee members was anti-Catholic and avowedly anti-Greene, (who's work was heavily religious).
But America, oddly enough, has one figure not award whom it defies my understanding why he wasn't acknowledged: Robert Penn Warren.
Robert Penn Warren was one of the major literary critics in America for forty years, he was the preeminent poet, (his work is amazing, he didn't win 3 Pulitzers for nothing), and he wrote several important fiction novels. He was basically an all around genius and man of letters. It really confuses me that not only was he not honored, but they choose Saul Bellow's collection of works about depressed college professors mulling philosophy and love affairs, over Warren when considering American authors. Or that they gave it to Isaac Singer, a thorough flop I think; no one in America reads Singer, and I really don't think many ever did.
The bigger issue with Warren is that in passing him up, the committee has thus never award the prize to an American poet; unless you count T.S. Elliot as an American, perhaps a half-American. Joseph Brodsky certainly doesn't count; he was a Russian, he wrote poetry in Russian even if he considered himself an American.
But Robert Penn Warren really was the preeminent figure I feel in the group of post-Faulkner Southern America writers including Carson McCullers, Flannery O'Conner, Eudora Welty, and Tennessee Williams.
I'll leave the floor open for additional bitching from the rest of you. I'm sure it will be quite entertaining and informative. Oh, and here is a Robert Penn Warren poem for ya folks:
I was going to say other things, but then it struck me that wow, has no other country been quite as thoroughly screwed over by the award as England? Here are the Britishers that won the award:
John Galsworthy
Ruyard Kipling
Bertrand Russell
Winston Churchill
William Golding
Harold Pinter
Doris Lessing
However,
E.M. Forester
D.H. Lawrence
Virginia Woolf
Dylan Thomas
E.H. Auden
W.E. Housmann
J.R. Tolkien
Graham Greene and
Evelyn Waugh
did not win. I can't think of any country that has been more screwed. William Golding was a lightweight with one so-so work, and they passed up Graham Greene's lifetime of work simply because one of the Committee members was anti-Catholic and avowedly anti-Greene, (who's work was heavily religious).
But America, oddly enough, has one figure not award whom it defies my understanding why he wasn't acknowledged: Robert Penn Warren.
Robert Penn Warren was one of the major literary critics in America for forty years, he was the preeminent poet, (his work is amazing, he didn't win 3 Pulitzers for nothing), and he wrote several important fiction novels. He was basically an all around genius and man of letters. It really confuses me that not only was he not honored, but they choose Saul Bellow's collection of works about depressed college professors mulling philosophy and love affairs, over Warren when considering American authors. Or that they gave it to Isaac Singer, a thorough flop I think; no one in America reads Singer, and I really don't think many ever did.
The bigger issue with Warren is that in passing him up, the committee has thus never award the prize to an American poet; unless you count T.S. Elliot as an American, perhaps a half-American. Joseph Brodsky certainly doesn't count; he was a Russian, he wrote poetry in Russian even if he considered himself an American.
But Robert Penn Warren really was the preeminent figure I feel in the group of post-Faulkner Southern America writers including Carson McCullers, Flannery O'Conner, Eudora Welty, and Tennessee Williams.
I'll leave the floor open for additional bitching from the rest of you. I'm sure it will be quite entertaining and informative. Oh, and here is a Robert Penn Warren poem for ya folks:
San Francisco Night Windows by Robert Penn WarrenSo hangs the hour like fruit fullblown and sweet,
Our strict and desperate avatar,
Despite that antique westward gulls lament
Over enormous waters which retreat
Weary unto the white and sensual star.
Accept these images for what they are--
Out of the past a fragile element
Of substance into accident.
I would speak honestly and of a full heart;
I would speak surely for the tale is short,
And the soul's remorseless catalogue
Assumes its quick and piteous sum.
Think you, hungry is the city in the fog
Where now the darkened piles resume
Their framed and frozen prayer
Articulate and shafted in the stone
Against the void and absolute air.
If so the frantic breath could be forgiven,
And the deep blood subdued before it is gone
In a savage paternoster to the stone,
Then might we all be shriven.